Products

Assorted Cookie Pie Pack
An assortment of all our famous Cookie Pie flavours making it a ridiculously yum treat for yourself or to make someone feel special <3  CAN BE SHIPPED NATIONWIDE NZ 5 x COOKIE PIE PACK INCLUDES: 1 each of Nutella Cookie Pies,...
from $25.00
Assorted Vegan Cookie Pie Pack
An assortment of all our Vegan Cookie Pie flavours making it a ridiculously yum treat for yourself or to make someone feel special <3  CAN BE SHIPPED NATIONWIDE NZ INCLUDES: 1 Cookies & Cream Cookie Pie, 2 Choc Chunk Cookie Pies & 2 Triple...
$25.00
Black Forest Cookie
Dark Whittaker’s chocolate & dried berries enveloped with premium Dutch cocoa dough. Rich, moist & incredibly moreish, this cookie has a cult following. Contains: Soy, Dairy, Eggs, Gluten May contain traces of: Peanuts, Nuts
$4.00
Caramilk Lovers Cookie Pie Pack
With our famous Moustache cookie dough encasing a gooey Caramilk centre, our Caramilk Cookie Pies are seriously A D D I C T I V E! Available in 5 Pack or 9 Pack & comes with Caramilk flavour ONLY. Contains:...
from $25.00
Choc Chunk Cookie
Ah the classic chocolate chunk. The quintessential cookie for dunking into a glass of cold milk. But this aint yo’ usual choco chunk cookie. We believe a good choc chunk has to have high quality chocolate and lots of it....
$4.00
Choc Chunk Cookie Pie (V)
( Contains: Soy, Nuts, Flour ) ( Produced in a kitchen that uses: Peanuts, Dairy, Eggs )
$3.90
Cinnamon Donut Cookie
The underdog of the cookie world. Whilst it may look plain, it is a staff favourite. This cookie tastes like a cinnamon donut, Easter & happiness all rolled into one. Soft, chewy and fluffy in texture, it works a treat...
$4.00
Classic Cookie Pie Pack
An assortment of our Classic Cookie Pie flavours inspired by the classic O.G Moustache cookies that we created way back in 2012 when we first opened (before we even created Cookie Pies!).  This cute gift pack makes for a ridiculously...
from $25.00
Cookie Cake
The famous Moustache Cookie Cake. Four giant sized cookies stacked together with three layers of beautiful dark chocolate ganache. Iconic & delicious. Perfect for any special occasion or no occasion at all. PICK UPS ONLY 6" Cookie Cake: recommended for 6-8 people...
$55.00
Cookies & (No) Cream Cookie Pie (V)
( Contains: Soy, Nuts, Flour ) ( Produced in a kitchen that uses: Peanuts, Dairy, Eggs )
$3.90
Sold Out
Festive Glitter Ribbon
$0.00
Giant Caramilk Pie
With our famous Moustache cookie dough encasing a gooey Caramilk centre, our Caramilk Cookie Pies are seriously A D D I C T I V E! Eat it as is or slice it up, warm it & top it with ice...
$39.00
Giant Caramilk Pie w/ Custom Choc Writing
Click here for the plain $39 Giant Caramilk Pie (with no custom choc writing on top) With our famous Moustache cookie dough encasing a gooey Caramilk centre, our Caramilk Cookie Pies are seriously A D D I C T I V...
$44.00
Giant Cookie
Choose any of our regular cookie flavours…only supersized! We can write a personalized message or customised drawing on your 22cm giant cookie making this a quirky & memorable gift.  Flavours Choc Chunk Contains: Soy, Dairy, Eggs, Gluten White Choc Macadamia...
$28.00
Giant Vegan Cookie (V/GF)
Our delicious Double Choc Chunk Vegan cookie…only super sized! We can write a personalised message on your 22cm giant cookie. Vegan & Gluten Free. Contains: Soy, Nuts Produced in a kitchen that uses: Peanuts, Flour, Dairy, Eggs
$29.00
Moustache Camp Mug
TAKING PRE-ORDERS ONLY: PLEASE SELECT MAY 5TH AT CHECKOUT. We will order your size and deliver at the start of May 2021. Rep your local Milk & Cookie Bar with our Moustache Camp Mug. Team up with friends and save!! Buy any...
$20.00
Moustache Tiered Cookie Cake
Our famous Moustache Cookie Cake just got more epic. Looking for a magnificently unique cake for a special occasion? Wedding? 21st? Big celebration? You need the MOUSTACHE TIERED COOKIE CAKE. Each tier is made up of giant Moustache Chocolate Chunk...
from $185.00
Nutella & Caramilk Cookie Pie Pack
Our famous Moustache Cookie Pies with a gooey Caramilk or Nutella centre. A ridiculously yum treat for yourself or to make a loved one feel special <3 CAN BE SHIPPED NATIONWIDE NZ 5 x COOKIE PIE PACK INCLUDES: 3 x...
from $25.00
Nutella Cookie
If you love Nutella, you’ll love this cookie. We pipe the smooth chocolate hazelnut spread into the centre of each cookie & top it off with crunchy hazelnuts. Contains: Soy, Nuts, Gluten, Dairy, Eggs May contain traces of: Peanuts
$4.00
Oreo Marshmallow Cookie
Melted marshmallow on the inside with crunchy marshmallow & crushed oreos on the outside. The cookie dough is made using premium Dutch cocoa that is produced in Holland from the finest West African Cocoa beans. It gives off a bittersweet...
$4.00
Party Pie
from $39.00
Party Pie
If you've ever been stuck on which cookie flavour to eat...then the Party Cookie Pie is for you because it is made up of EVERY. SINGLE. COOKIE. FLAVOUR. Eat it as is or slice it up, warm it & top...
from $39.00
Peanut Butter Cookie
Peanut Butter lovers unite. We hand-pipe peanut butter straight into the centre of the cookie and top it with rich Whittaker’s chocolate. Dunk it in cold milk & you’ve got yourself a good day. ( Contains: Peanuts, Nuts, Soy, Dairy, Eggs,...
$4.00
Snickers Bar Cookie
We managed to shove half a Snickers Bar in this cookie to form a chewy, nougaty, caramelly, nutty and incredibly popular cookie. You won’t want to share this one so make sure you get more than one. ( Contains: Peanuts,...
$4.00
You have successfully subscribed!