Cookie Pies

Filter below for delivery, vegan, and best sellers.

Cookie Pies

manual

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Vegan Options Available
Afterpay Available
NZ Wide Delivery

“I ordered a chocolate shake and a caramel cookie pie, which were scrumptious! They were so good that I came back about 20 minutes later to get two more cookie pies, trying a cookies and cream one the second time. I’d definitely recommend this place if you’ve got a sweet tooth.”


- Ashok Sivaraja

“I got the 3 assorted cookie pies for $19 and they were honestly just amazing the cookies were baked perfectly slightly crunchy on the outside, warm and gooey on the inside and it was just the perfect amount of sweet (with milk) my family and I absolutely loved it. Thank you Moustache!!!”

- Jess

“I ordered the Cookie Pie Bundle & a Giant Cookie with a personalized message for a birthday, & I couldn't be happier! The treats were absolutely delicious, hands down the tastiest I've ever had. The packaging was impeccable, clearly done with great care!”

- Grace Voorhoeve

“When I tell y’all I came here nearly everyday I ain’t joking!
It’s worth the money especially the thick shakes! They have both a vegan and non vegan options for drinks so it caters to all and don’t get me started on them cookie pies; always a fresh batch away!!”

- Silofa Manttan

“I’ve been wanting to try Moustache for yearssss now & happened to be in town from Levin. They are HEAVENNNNNN! My partner declares that every time we’re in Auckland, we have to stop here! Winningggg! Thank you for everything team! We are coming back for sure !”

- Carla Marupo-Gataulu

“Love the cookies and milkshakes. Have been back twice as soon loved the cookies we took home. Many different varieties of cookies and cookie pies. Definitely a place to go and get fresh, soft cookies. Will be back for many more visits. Staff are very friendly and helpful.”

- Libby